Stores Like Spencer’s: 12 Novelty & Gag-Gift Retailers Worth a Look
Text
About Spencer's
Founded
1947
USA
Ships to
US, Canada
Editor-reviewed
Every recommendation read and refined by hand
Honest tradeoffs
Drawbacks listed, not hidden
No paid placements
Brands cannot pay to be ranked
Who actually shops Spencer's now? The honest answer: a 17-year-old buying a beer-pong-slogan tee and a lava lamp for a first apartment, plus the aunt who needs a gag gift for a bachelorette party and remembers the store from her own mall days. That's a narrower crowd than it used to be.
For decades the black-walled storefront near the food court did one thing brilliantly — you walked past the blacklight posters, the drinkware with rude captions, the shot glasses shaped like things you can't describe at Thanksgiving, and the wall of Bob Marley and Nirvana merch, and you left with something that made a friend laugh. It thrived on impulse and the specific thrill of being 16 and allowed inside.
But the mall foot traffic that fed those impulse buys keeps shrinking, and the humor-plus-band-merch formula now competes with a dozen sites that ship the same gags cheaper.
Spencer's leans hard on Spirit Halloween each October to carry the year, which tells you where the actual momentum went. If you're hunting for the party supplies, the pop-culture apparel, or the genuinely funny gag gift without circling a dying mall, look toward outfits like Hot Topic — which turned fandom merch into a destination rather than a novelty shelf — and Vat19, which built an entire brand on the absurd impulse gift Spencer's used to own.
For decades the black-walled storefront near the food court did one thing brilliantly — you walked past the blacklight posters, the drinkware with rude captions, the shot glasses shaped like things you can't describe at Thanksgiving, and the wall of Bob Marley and Nirvana merch, and you left with something that made a friend laugh. It thrived on impulse and the specific thrill of being 16 and allowed inside.
But the mall foot traffic that fed those impulse buys keeps shrinking, and the humor-plus-band-merch formula now competes with a dozen sites that ship the same gags cheaper.
Spencer's leans hard on Spirit Halloween each October to carry the year, which tells you where the actual momentum went. If you're hunting for the party supplies, the pop-culture apparel, or the genuinely funny gag gift without circling a dying mall, look toward outfits like Hot Topic — which turned fandom merch into a destination rather than a novelty shelf — and Vat19, which built an entire brand on the absurd impulse gift Spencer's used to own.
Quick decision
Narrow it down
Price
Best for
Jump to a brand
12 brands
The 12 Best Alternatives to Spencer's
1
Hot Topic
Est. 1989
City of Industry, California, USA
Sizes XS-3X
≈
similar
Pop-culture and band-tee shoppers who outgrew the novelty shelf
The other mall-anchored edgy retailer, but Hot Topic went all-in on licensed fandom apparel, anime, and band merch instead of gag gifts.
Pros
- Massive licensed catalog: anime, Disney, gaming, K-pop
- Strong plus-size and inclusive apparel range
- Frequent BOGO and clearance deals
Cons
- Heavy graphic-tee focus, thin on party supplies
- Quality varies wildly by license and price
2
Vat19
Est. 2007
St. Louis, Missouri, USA
≈
similar
Gag-gift and weird-candy buyers who want it shipped
Built its whole identity on absurd, impulse-buy gag gifts and novelty candy — the exact 'that made me laugh' aisle Spencer's used to own.
Pros
- Genuinely funny, well-curated gag gifts
- Entertaining product videos help you pick
- Strong giant-candy and prank-gift selection
Cons
- Online only, no impulse browsing
- Some items pricier than their novelty value
3
BoxLunch
Est. 2015
City of Industry, California, USA
Sizes XS-3X
≈
similar
Fandom shoppers who want a feel-good spend
1% for the Planet
Licensed pop-culture apparel and collectibles like Hot Topic, but with a charity give-back on purchases — a fandom-merch destination.
Pros
- Donates a meal for every $10 spent via Feeding America
- Broad licensed apparel and collectible range
- Regular exclusive drops
Cons
- Prices skew higher than generic novelty
- Inventory overlaps heavily with sister brand Hot Topic
4
Party City
Est. 1986
Woodcliff Lake, New Jersey, USA
$
cheaper
Party planners and bulk decoration buyers
The go-to for party supplies, decorations, and gag balloons — the party-goods half of Spencer's minus the adult humor.
Pros
- Enormous themed party and balloon selection
- Cheap bulk supplies for events
- Strong seasonal and licensed party lines
Cons
- Family-friendly, none of the adult-humor edge
- Store closures have thinned physical locations
Visit Party City
Full guide: Stores Like Party City
5
Prank-O / Prank Pack
Est. 2010
USA
$
cheaper
Birthday and white-elephant gift pranksters
Specializes in fake gift boxes for real presents — pure gag-gift comedy, the wrapping-a-real-gift-in-something-embarrassing trick.
Pros
- Clever, low-cost prank gift boxes
- Widely available on Amazon and in stores
- Great for reusable wrapping gags
Cons
- One-trick product line
- Gag wears off after the reveal
6
RedBubble
Est. 2006
Melbourne, Australia
Sizes XS-3XL
≈
similar
Shoppers hunting a specific niche or in-joke design
A print-on-demand marketplace with millions of edgy, funny, and fandom designs on tees, mugs, and stickers — the graphic-humor apparel Spencer's stocks, but infinite.
Pros
- Endless independent artist designs
- Supports individual creators directly
- Covers apparel, stickers, home goods, phone cases
Cons
- Print quality and sizing vary by product
- Shipping times can be long
7
Something Wild!
Est. 1998
USA
≈
similar
Bachelorette and adult-party gag shopping
An adult-humor novelty and party retailer covering the risqué gag gifts, drinkware, and bachelorette supplies at the core of Spencer's mix.
Pros
- Deep adult-humor and bachelorette catalog
- Bulk party-favor options
- The exact risqué niche Spencer's serves
Cons
- Dated site experience
- Narrow appeal outside adult parties
8
Newbury Comics
Est. 1978
Boston, Massachusetts, USA
≈
similar
Music-merch and vinyl collectors who want novelty too
A New England chain mixing band merch, vinyl, pop-culture toys, and quirky novelty gifts — the FYE-meets-Spencer's blend done with better taste.
Pros
- Excellent vinyl and exclusive color pressings
- Strong band-tee and pop-culture toy mix
- Curated, less generic than mall novelty
Cons
- Mostly regional store presence
- Less focus on party supplies and gags
9
Perpetual Kid
Est. 2002
USA
$
cheaper
Stocking-stuffer and desk-toy gift buyers
An online novelty gift shop stuffed with silly desk toys, weird kitchen gadgets, and gag gifts — pure impulse-purchase energy.
Pros
- Huge cheap-and-cheerful novelty range
- Great for stocking stuffers and Secret Santa
- Frequent sitewide sales
Cons
- Some items feel disposable
- Lighter on apparel and band merch
10
Firebox
Est. 1998
London, UK
$$$
pricier
Shoppers wanting cleverer, less crude novelty gifts
UK novelty gift specialist with sharp, irreverent gadgets and adult-humor gifts — a wittier, more design-led take on the gag aisle.
Pros
- Well-designed, genuinely clever gifts
- Strong booze and gadget novelty range
- Better build quality than mall gags
Cons
- UK-based, pricier shipping to US
- Higher price point overall
11
Spirit Halloween
Est. 1983
Egg Harbor Township, New Jersey, USA
≈
similar
Halloween costumes, decor, and seasonal party props
Spencer's own seasonal sister brand — the costume, animatronic, and party-prop powerhouse that carries the parent company each fall.
Pros
- Unmatched Halloween costume and animatronic range
- Pop-up stores nationwide each fall
- Strong licensed costume lineup
Cons
- Seasonal — mostly closed outside autumn
- Only overlaps with the Halloween slice of Spencer's
12
TeeTurtle
Est. 2011
St. Louis, Missouri, USA
Sizes XS-3XL
≈
similar
Anime, gaming, and cute-nerdy graphic-tee fans
Cute-meets-nerdy graphic apparel and viral novelty (the Reversible Octopus plush) — the fandom-humor tee niche with a wholesome twist.
Pros
- Original, non-crude nerdy designs
- Home of the viral reversible mood plush
- Regular new drops and card games
Cons
- No party supplies or gags
- Leans cute rather than edgy
Cheapest impulse-buy gags
For the under-$15 laugh Spencer's built its business on, Prank-O's fake gift boxes and Perpetual Kid's silly desk toys deliver the most comedy per dollar. Party City covers cheap bulk decorations and balloons if you're stocking an event rather than gifting one person. All three skip the mall markup.
Best for pop-culture & band merch
If you came to Spencer's for the wall of band tees and licensed apparel rather than the gag shelf, Hot Topic and BoxLunch offer far deeper fandom catalogs. Newbury Comics adds vinyl and exclusive pressings, while TeeTurtle handles the cute-nerdy anime and gaming lane with original designs.
Adult-humor & party specialists
For the risqué bachelorette gags, rude drinkware, and grown-up party favors, Something Wild! covers the crude-humor niche directly and Firebox does a wittier, design-led version. Spirit Halloween — Spencer's own sister brand — still owns the fall costume-and-prop season outright.Which Alternative Is Right for You?
Want the pop-culture apparel without the gag shelf? Hot Topic and BoxLunch are the clear moves, with BoxLunch adding a meal donation on every $10 spent. Chasing a specific in-joke or niche design? RedBubble's print-on-demand marketplace has millions of them. If it's pure gag-gift comedy you're after, Vat19 and Prank-O do the absurd-impulse-buy thing better than a fading mall shelf, and Perpetual Kid wins on price for stocking stuffers. Planning an actual party? Party City handles bulk supplies cheaply, Something Wild! covers the adult-humor bachelorette stuff, and Spirit Halloween remains the October answer. For cleverer, better-built novelty, Firebox is worth the higher shipping. Frequently Asked Questions
QWhat stores are like Spencer's but online only?
Vat19, Perpetual Kid, Prank-O, RedBubble, and Firebox all cover the novelty, gag-gift, and edgy-apparel territory without needing a mall trip. Vat19 and Perpetual Kid are strongest for impulse gifts, while RedBubble handles the infinite graphic-tee niche.
QWhere can I buy band tees and pop-culture merch instead of Spencer's?
Hot Topic has the deepest licensed apparel catalog — anime, gaming, K-pop, and band merch. BoxLunch is its give-back sibling, and Newbury Comics adds vinyl and exclusive pressings alongside band tees and pop-culture toys.
QIs Spirit Halloween the same company as Spencer's?
Yes. Spirit Halloween is Spencer's seasonal sister brand, and its fall costume-and-animatronic business effectively carries the parent company each year. It's the best place for Halloween costumes and party props, but mostly operates only in autumn.
QWhere can I find adult-humor gag gifts for a bachelorette party?
Something Wild! specializes directly in risqué bachelorette supplies, rude drinkware, and adult-party favors. Firebox offers a wittier, design-led version of the same category, and Prank-O covers the fake-gift-box prank angle cheaply.
QWhat's a better-quality alternative to Spencer's cheap novelty items?
Firebox stands out for genuinely clever, well-built gadgets and gifts, though shipping from the UK costs more. For apparel, TeeTurtle and Hot Topic both offer sturdier graphic tees than a typical mall novelty shelf, with TeeTurtle leaning cute-nerdy and original.
Our Verdict
The Best Spencer's Alternative For You
Want the pop-culture apparel without the gag shelf? Hot Topic and BoxLunch are the clear moves, with BoxLunch adding a meal donation on every $10 spent. Chasing a specific in-joke or niche design? RedBubble's print-on-demand marketplace has millions of them. If it's pure gag-gift comedy you're after, Vat19 and Prank-O do the absurd-impulse-buy thing better than a fading mall shelf, and Perpetual Kid wins on price for stocking stuffers. Planning an actual party? Party City handles bulk supplies cheaply, Something Wild! covers the adult-humor bachelorette stuff, and Spirit Halloween remains the October answer. For cleverer, better-built novelty, Firebox is worth the higher shipping.