Stores Like DSW: 12 Off-Price Shoe Retailers Worth Switching To
Text
About DSW
Founded
1991
USA
Ships to
US, Canada
Editor-reviewed
Every recommendation read and refined by hand
Honest tradeoffs
Drawbacks listed, not hidden
No paid placements
Brands cannot pay to be ranked
The appeal of DSW was the hunt that paid off — walking those long aisles of clear boxes and finding Steve Madden boots, a pair of Cole Haan loafers, or Birkenstock Arizonas marked down enough to feel like you'd outsmarted a department store. The VIP rewards program made it stickier than the competition: spend, earn points, get a $10 or $20 reward certificate that landed in your inbox right when you were about to buy anyway. Free shipping for members, in-store returns, the occasional clearance rack that genuinely surprised you.
That machine still runs. What's thinned is the reason to make the trip.
The in-store inventory has become a coin flip — one location stocks deep in size 9, the next is picked clean of anything you'd actually wear. The designer selection that once justified the "Designer Shoe Warehouse" name now reads more midmarket than premium, and Nordstrom Rack quietly carries the better names at comparable discounts. The athletic wall feels like an afterthought next to dedicated sneaker sellers. So when the shoe you want isn't in your size and the markdown isn't quite the steal it used to be, where do you actually go to find brand-name footwear without paying full retail?
That machine still runs. What's thinned is the reason to make the trip.
The in-store inventory has become a coin flip — one location stocks deep in size 9, the next is picked clean of anything you'd actually wear. The designer selection that once justified the "Designer Shoe Warehouse" name now reads more midmarket than premium, and Nordstrom Rack quietly carries the better names at comparable discounts. The athletic wall feels like an afterthought next to dedicated sneaker sellers. So when the shoe you want isn't in your size and the markdown isn't quite the steal it used to be, where do you actually go to find brand-name footwear without paying full retail?
Quick decision
Narrow it down
Price
Best for
Jump to a brand
12 brands
The 12 Best Alternatives to DSW
1
Nordstrom Rack
Est. 1973
Seattle, USA
≈
similar
Shoppers who want genuine designer names at a discount
The most direct upgrade — off-price brand-name shoes, but with a deeper bench of actual designer and premium labels than DSW now carries, plus Nordstrom's return policy backing it.
Pros
- Deeper premium and designer selection than DSW
- Nordstrom's generous, no-drama return policy
- Strong online clearance and Clear the Rack events
Cons
- Inventory varies wildly between locations
- Best designer finds disappear fast online
Visit Nordstrom Rack
Full guide: Stores Like Nordstrom Rack
2
Famous Footwear
Est. 1960
St. Louis, USA
$
cheaper
Family shoe shopping across athletic and casual
The closest peer to DSW's mainstream mix — Nike, Skechers, Crocs, Vans at family-friendly prices, with a Rewards program built around the same points-and-coupons mechanic.
Pros
- Strong athletic and kids' selection
- Frequent BOGO and percent-off promotions
- Rewards program rivals DSW VIP
Cons
- Less designer or dress footwear than DSW
- Store stock skews to mass-market athletic brands
3
Zappos
Est. 1999
Las Vegas, USA
$$$
pricier
Anyone burned by empty shelves in their size
The online answer to DSW's size-availability problem — enormous catalog, free shipping both ways, 365-day returns, and customer service that's borderline legendary.
Pros
- Massive inventory and width/size options
- Free shipping and 365-day returns
- Best-in-class customer service
Cons
- Mostly full retail, not discount
- No physical stores to try on
4
6pm
Est. 2007
Las Vegas, USA
$
cheaper
Online bargain hunters who don't need it this week
Zappos' clearance sibling — the same broad brand catalog but marked down hard, making it the online version of digging through a DSW clearance rack.
Pros
- Steep discounts on real brands
- Backed by Zappos' fulfillment
- Great for hard-to-find sizes on clearance
Cons
- Final-sale items have stricter returns
- Stock is last-season and unpredictable
5
Shoe Carnival
Est. 1978
Evansville, USA
$
cheaper
Deal-driven shoppers who love a promotion
A direct off-price competitor with a louder, promo-driven floor — the spin-the-wheel discounts and BOGO deals make it feel like DSW with a carnival barker.
Pros
- Aggressive in-store promotions and BOGO
- Strong family and athletic selection
- Shoe Perks loyalty program
Cons
- Limited reach outside the Midwest and South
- Less premium and dress selection
6
Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse
Est. 1991
Nashville, USA
≈
similar
Shoppers who like the warehouse browsing format
Off-price warehouse format nearly identical to DSW's clear-box browsing experience, with a similar mix of brand-name casual and dress shoes.
Pros
- Same self-serve warehouse browsing as DSW
- Solid mix of dress and casual brands
- Loyalty rewards program
Cons
- Smaller store footprint and reach
- Inventory depth varies by location
7
Macy's
Est. 1858
New York, USA
≈
similar
Dress and designer shoes during sale events
The department-store shoe floor DSW once tried to undercut — frequent sales, coupons, and a designer assortment, plus Star Rewards points that work like DSW VIP.
Pros
- Broad designer and dress footwear range
- Constant coupon and sale cadence
- Star Rewards points program
Cons
- Full price is steep without a sale
- Shoe departments shrinking in some stores
Visit Macy's
Full guide: Stores Like Macy's
8
TJ Maxx
Est. 1976
Framingham, USA
$
cheaper
Patient bargain hunters chasing designer names
The original treasure-hunt off-price model — designer shoes turn up at deeper discounts than DSW, though you're entirely at the mercy of what's in the bins that week.
Pros
- Deeper designer discounts than DSW
- New shipments constantly
- TJX Rewards program and store card
Cons
- Pure luck of the draw on stock
- No organized size runs
9
Rack Room Shoes
Est. 1920
Charlotte, USA
$
cheaper
Family footwear in the Southeast
A self-service family shoe chain with the same buy-one-get-one promo rhythm and athletic-plus-casual mix that defines DSW's mainstream floor.
Pros
- Regular BOGO 1/2-off events
- Good kids' and athletic selection
- Rewards Club loyalty program
Cons
- Concentrated in the Southeast
- Thin on premium and designer brands
10
Nike
Est. 1964
Beaverton, USA
$$$
pricier
Sneaker shoppers who want full selection
If the athletic wall is what you came to DSW for, going direct gets you the full lineup, exclusive colorways, and Nike Member rewards instead of picked-over leftovers.
Pros
- Full lineup including exclusives
- Nike Member perks and early access
- Reliable sizing and direct returns
Cons
- Single-brand only
- Full retail unless you hit the outlet section
Visit Nike
Full guide: Stores Like Nike
11
Steve Madden
Est. 1990
Long Island City, USA
≈
similar
On-trend dress and casual shoes for women
DSW leaned heavily on Steve Madden in its trendier aisles — buying direct gets you the full current range plus the outlet section for the same kind of markdowns.
Pros
- Full current collection, not leftovers
- Outlet section for marked-down styles
- Strong trend-driven women's selection
Cons
- Single brand only
- Quality is fashion-grade, not heirloom
12
Allbirds
Est. 2015
San Francisco, USA
$$$
pricier
Sustainability-minded casual shoe buyers
B Corp
Carbon Neutral
For shoppers leaving DSW because they want fewer, better, more sustainable shoes rather than a wall of disposable options — a focused merino and eucalyptus lineup.
Pros
- Certified B Corp with carbon labeling
- Machine-washable merino comfort
- Minimal, versatile everyday styles
Cons
- Tiny range compared to DSW
- Full price only, rarely discounted
Best for empty-shelf frustration (shop online)
DSW's biggest weakness is the in-store size lottery. Zappos solves it outright with a massive catalog, free returns, and width options most stores skip. For the same brands marked down, 6pm is the clearance arm — same warehouse, last-season prices. TJ Maxx and TJX online surface designer names if you're willing to dig and accept the luck of the draw.
Best for genuine bargains under DSW pricing
If the markdowns at DSW stopped feeling like steals, these go lower. Famous Footwear and Rack Room Shoes run near-constant BOGO half-off events on mainstream brands. Shoe Carnival piles on spin-the-wheel and stackable promos. TJ Maxx and 6pm both routinely beat DSW on the same labels if you're patient.
Best for real designer selection
The name says Designer Shoe Warehouse, but the assortment drifted midmarket. Nordstrom Rack carries the better premium labels at comparable discounts with a far friendlier return policy. Macy's designer floor delivers during its frequent sale events, and TJ Maxx occasionally turns up genuine designer footwear at the deepest cuts of anyone here.Which Alternative Is Right for You?
Go to Nordstrom Rack if your real complaint is that DSW stopped feeling like a designer store — it carries the premium names DSW lost, at similar discounts, with returns that don't fight you. Pick Famous Footwear or Rack Room Shoes if you mostly bought athletic and family shoes and want a lower price with the same points-and-coupons rhythm. Choose Zappos when the size-availability problem is the dealbreaker; 6pm if you want that same catalog discounted. Shoe Carnival and Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse keep the warehouse browsing experience nearly intact. For trend-driven women's styles, going direct to Steve Madden gets the full current range instead of leftovers. And if leaving DSW is really about wanting fewer, better shoes, Allbirds is the sustainable pivot — a small, focused lineup instead of a wall of options. Frequently Asked Questions
QIs Nordstrom Rack better than DSW for designer shoes?
For genuine premium and designer labels, yes. Nordstrom Rack consistently carries higher-end names than DSW now stocks, at comparable discounts, and backs them with Nordstrom's lenient return policy. DSW still wins on mainstream athletic and casual brands and on its VIP rewards program, but if the 'designer' in Designer Shoe Warehouse is what you're after, the Rack delivers more of it.
QWhich store has better deals than DSW?
Famous Footwear, Rack Room Shoes, and Shoe Carnival all run frequent BOGO half-off and stackable promotions that often undercut DSW on mainstream brands. For online clearance, 6pm and TJ Maxx routinely beat DSW pricing on the same labels — the tradeoff is unpredictable stock and stricter returns on final-sale items.
QWhere can I find my size if DSW is always out of stock?
Zappos is the fix for the in-store size lottery — it carries deep size and width runs, ships free both ways, and takes returns for a full year. 6pm offers the same broad catalog at clearance prices, and Steve Madden or Nike sell direct if you want guaranteed availability in a specific brand's full range.
QDoes any store have a loyalty program as good as DSW VIP?
DSW VIP is genuinely one of the better footwear rewards programs, but Famous Footwear Rewards, Shoe Carnival's Shoe Perks, and Rack Room's Rewards Club all use a similar points-and-certificates model. Macy's Star Rewards works comparably if you buy shoes during its frequent sale events. None is dramatically better than DSW's — they're roughly equivalent.
QWhat's the best alternative to DSW for sustainable or fewer-but-better shoes?
If you're leaving DSW because a warehouse wall of disposable options no longer appeals, Allbirds is the cleanest pivot — a Certified B Corp with a small, focused merino and eucalyptus lineup and carbon labeling on every shoe. You'll pay full retail and get far fewer choices, but that's the point: fewer, better, longer-lasting pairs instead of the hunt.
Our Verdict
The Best DSW Alternative For You
Go to Nordstrom Rack if your real complaint is that DSW stopped feeling like a designer store — it carries the premium names DSW lost, at similar discounts, with returns that don't fight you. Pick Famous Footwear or Rack Room Shoes if you mostly bought athletic and family shoes and want a lower price with the same points-and-coupons rhythm. Choose Zappos when the size-availability problem is the dealbreaker; 6pm if you want that same catalog discounted. Shoe Carnival and Off Broadway Shoe Warehouse keep the warehouse browsing experience nearly intact. For trend-driven women's styles, going direct to Steve Madden gets the full current range instead of leftovers. And if leaving DSW is really about wanting fewer, better shoes, Allbirds is the sustainable pivot — a small, focused lineup instead of a wall of options.